subscribe to our mailing list:
|
SECTIONS
|
 |
|
|
Letters
[Write a Reply]
[Letters Index]
| Title |
Author |
Date |
| clarification |
e.j.levin@stir.ac.uk |
Nov 12, 2004
|
I was very surprised to read the text (pasted below) on your website http://www.talkreason.org/articles/Morality.cfm
For the avoidance of doubt, I would be grateful if you would provide me with the references to Talmudic sources that prohibit Jews from saving the lives of endangered gentiles, that oblige the Jews to maltreat gentiles in commercial transactions, that make it permissible and even obligatory to deceive gentiles in certain cases, that permit Jews to appropriate the money and property borrowed from a gentile in the case of the latter's death, that forbid Jews to return objects lost by a gentile.
Thank you
Eric Levin
"Today these communities are permitted to save the lives of sick gentiles, to return the objects lost by gentiles, and to conduct honest business dealings with gentiles. As we know, classical Jewish sources beginning with the Talmud categorically rejected the very idea of equality between Jews and gentiles. For example, these sources impose an automatic death sentence on anyone they define as an idolater; in most cases they prohibit Jews from saving the lives of endangered gentiles, oblige the Jews to maltreat gentiles in commercial transactions, make it permissible and even obligatory to deceive gentiles in certain cases, and so on. Among other things, these sources (hereinafter referred to as "Halachah" for the sake of brevity) permit Jews to appropriate the money and property borrowed from a gentile in the case of the latter's death, and even to lie to his heirs regarding their financial relations with the deceased; forbid Jews to return objects lost by a gentile, and permit Jews to exploit a miscalculation made by a gentile, provided the mistake benefits the Jew."
|
| Related Articles: |
Some remarks regarding comparative morality
|
| Title |
Author |
Date |
| clarification |
TalkReason , |
Nov 14, 2004
|
Dear Mr. Levin,
The Talk Reason article Judaic sources on the attitude towards gentiles (http://www.talkreason.org/articles/gentiles.cfm) by Leon Zilberstein et
al. includes a .pdf file with "major relevant excerpts from classical Jewish halachic sources (far from complete, indeed, patently incomplete), which form the foundation of the precepts in question." This file is 73 pages long but hopefully it will answer your questions.
If, though, you have additional
questions, don't hesitate to ask them.
Best wishes,
TalkReason
|
| Related Articles: |
Some remarks regarding comparative morality
|
|
|
